At the NAIC Summer Meeting in New York on August 4, 2019, the NAIC’s Restructuring Mechanisms Working Group (“Restructuring Working Group”) held its meeting on insurance business transfers (“IBTs”) and corporate division statutes. The Restructuring Working Group (and its Subgroup which is working on accounting and related subjects) continue to gather information on this important industry development.
As noted in a previous Locke Lord client alert on this issue, U.S. reinsurers and insurers are looking for new solutions to provide economic and legal finality to transfers of legacy insurance risks as a means to improve the efficient allocation of capital and management resources to both legacy and on-going insurance operations. As of this date, Rhode Island, Oklahoma, Arizona, Connecticut, Illinois, Iowa, Michigan, Pennsylvania and Vermont have adopted IBT or corporate division statutes with varying requirements and procedures to segregate insurers’ books of business.
At this meeting, the Restructuring Working Group adopted minutes of the Spring National Meeting and subsequent interim meetings, which included the July 1 updated and proposed changes to the Restructuring Working Group’s and Subgroup’s charges for 2020. When the two groups were formed in early 2019, it was hoped that they would complete work on their charges by the end of this year. One of those charges for the Restructuring Working Group, whose co-chairs are Elizabeth Dwyer from Rhode Island and Buddy Combs from Oklahoma, is the evaluation and preparation of a White Paper to address (a) the perceived need for restructuring statutes, the issues those statutes are designed to remedy and alternatives that insurers are currently employing to achieve similar results; (b) the existing state insurance company restructuring statutes; and (c) legal issues posed by an IBT court order (or a corporate division) effected in one state that affects the policyholders or cedents in other states. The White Paper is also expected to address the impact that a restructuring of an insurer might have on state insurance guaranty funds’ coverage of transferred policyholders and the legal and accounting issues associated with restructurings that use protected cells. The target date for completion of the White Paper is now the Summer of 2020.
The Restructuring Working Group also adopted a revised charge to request that the Executive (EX) Committee approve the development of changes to NAIC model laws and regulations to accommodate the findings that might come from the White Paper. It is expected that those findings would be ready for action by appropriate NAIC Committees by the 2020 Fall National Meeting.
The Subgroup, whose co-chairs are Dave Smith and Doug Stolte from Virginia, and Jack Broccoli, from Rhode Island, has its own charges for 2020, which include developing best practices for: (a) reviewing proposed restructuring transactions including, the expected level of reserves and capital expected after the transfer, and (b) monitoring insurers after restructuring. The target date for completion of this charge is also the 2020 Summer National Meeting.
The Subgroup is also charged with (a) considering the need to make changes to the RBC formula to better assess the minimum surplus requirements for companies in runoff, and (b) reviewing the various restructuring mechanisms and developing, if needed, protected cell accounting and reporting requirements. Those charges are to be completed by the 2020 Fall National Meeting. Any recommended changes to the RBC formula or protected cell accounting would be referred to the NAIC Working Groups responsible for those subjects.
A number of issues and conceptual uncertainties continued to dog the discussions of IBTs and restructuring proposals, not only at the Restructuring Working Group but also among proponents and opponents of the proposals.
Locke Lord will continue to monitor and report on the progress of the Restructuring Working Group and Subgroup and any new developments with respect to the use of IBTs in the U.S.
Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest to your inbox.